Used ChatGPT to fix some issues with the VaR

This commit is contained in:
2026-02-19 20:10:06 -05:00
parent 6d966c4f28
commit f248701d17
3 changed files with 283 additions and 213 deletions

View File

@@ -1,120 +1,148 @@
using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;
using System.Collections.Generic;
namespace MarketData.ValueAtRisk
{
public class BinResult<T>
{
public double Value{get;private set;}
public T Item{get;private set;}
public BinResult()
public double Value { get; private set; }
public T Item { get; private set; }
public BinResult() { }
public BinResult(double value, T item)
{
}
public BinResult(double value,T item)
{
this.Value=value;
this.Item=item;
this.Value = value;
this.Item = item;
}
}
public class BinManager<T>
{
private List<BinItem<T>> binItems;
private long binCount;
private long samples;
public BinManager(long binCount=100)
public BinManager(long binCount = 100)
{
this.binCount = binCount;
InitializeBins();
}
private void InitializeBins()
{
this.binItems = new List<BinItem<T>>();
this.samples=0;
this.samples = 0;
}
public BinResult<T> GetVaRReturn(double[] values,List<T> items,double percentile)
public BinResult<T> GetVaRReturn(double[] values, List<T> items, double percentile)
{
double minValue = float.NaN;
double maxValue = float.NaN;
double binSize = double.NaN;
T item=default(T);
T item = default(T);
InitializeBins();
GetMinMax(ref minValue,ref maxValue,values);
binSize=(maxValue-minValue)/(double)binCount;
for (double value = minValue; value < maxValue; value += binSize)
GetMinMax(ref minValue, ref maxValue, values);
binSize = (maxValue - minValue) / (double)binCount;
if (binSize == 0) binSize = 1e-10;
// Create bins
for (double value = minValue; value <= maxValue; value += binSize)
{
binItems.Add(new BinItem<T>(value));
}
// Add values and objects to bins
for (int index = 0; index < values.Length; index++)
{
AddValueToBin(values[index]);
AddObjectToBin(values[index],items[index]);
AddObjectToBin(values[index], items[index]);
}
double samplesAtRank = samples-(samples * (percentile/100.00));
double samplesAtRank = samples - (samples * (percentile / 100.0));
if (samplesAtRank < 1) samplesAtRank = 1;
long samplesInRank = 0;
double percentVaR = 0;
for (int index = 0; index < binItems.Count; index++)
{
BinItem<T> binItem = binItems[index];
samplesInRank += binItem.BinCount;
percentVaR = binItem.BinValue;
item=binItem.BinObject;
item = binItem.BinObject;
if (samplesInRank > samplesAtRank) break;
}
return new BinResult<T>(percentVaR,item);
return new BinResult<T>(percentVaR, item);
}
public double GetVaRReturn(double[] values,double percentile)
public double GetVaRReturn(double[] values, double percentile)
{
double minValue = float.NaN;
double maxValue = float.NaN;
double binSize = double.NaN;
InitializeBins();
GetMinMax(ref minValue,ref maxValue,values);
binSize=(maxValue-minValue)/(double)binCount;
for (double value = minValue; value < maxValue; value += binSize)
GetMinMax(ref minValue, ref maxValue, values);
binSize = (maxValue - minValue) / (double)binCount;
if (binSize == 0) binSize = 1e-10;
// Create bins
for (double value = minValue; value <= maxValue; value += binSize)
{
binItems.Add(new BinItem<T>(value));
}
// Add values to bins
for (int index = 0; index < values.Length; index++)
{
AddValueToBin(values[index]);
}
double samplesAtRank = samples-(samples * (percentile/100.00));
double samplesAtRank = samples - (samples * (percentile / 100.0));
if (samplesAtRank < 1) samplesAtRank = 1;
long samplesInRank = 0;
double percentVaR = 0;
for (int index = 0; index < binItems.Count; index++)
{
BinItem<T> binItem = binItems[index];
samplesInRank += binItem.BinCount;
percentVaR = binItem.BinValue;
if (samplesInRank > samplesAtRank) break;
}
return percentVaR;
}
private static void GetMinMax(ref double minValue,ref double maxValue,double[] values)
private static void GetMinMax(ref double minValue, ref double maxValue, double[] values)
{
for (int index = 0; index < values.Length; index++)
{
double value = values[index];
if (0 == index)
if (index == 0)
{
minValue = maxValue = value;
continue;
}
if (value > maxValue) maxValue = value;
if (value < minValue) minValue = value;
}
}
private void AddValueToBin(double value)
{
bool added = false;
samples++;
for (int index = 0; index < binItems.Count; index++)
{
BinItem<T> binItem = binItems[index];
@@ -125,23 +153,28 @@ namespace MarketData.ValueAtRisk
break;
}
}
if (false == added && binItems.Count>0) binItems[binItems.Count - 1].BinCount++;
if (!added && binItems.Count > 0)
binItems[binItems.Count - 1].BinCount++;
}
private void AddObjectToBin(double value,T item)
private void AddObjectToBin(double value, T item)
{
bool added = false;
// samples++;
for (int index = 0; index < binItems.Count; index++)
{
BinItem<T> binItem = binItems[index];
if (value <= binItem.BinValue)
{
binItem.BinObject=item;
binItem.BinObject = item;
added = true;
break;
}
}
if (false == added && binItems.Count>0) binItems[binItems.Count - 1].BinObject=item;
if (!added && binItems.Count > 0)
binItems[binItems.Count - 1].BinObject = item;
}
}
}

View File

@@ -1,9 +1,5 @@
using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;
using MarketData.DataAccess;
using MarketData.Utils;
namespace MarketData.ValueAtRisk
{
@@ -11,81 +7,123 @@ namespace MarketData.ValueAtRisk
{
private int returnDays = 1;
private HistoricalVaR()
private HistoricalVaR() { }
public static VaRResult GetVaR(PortfolioHoldings portfolioHoldings, double percentile, int returnDays = 1)
{
}
public static VaRResult GetVaR(PortfolioHoldings portfolioHoldings, double percentile,int returnDays=1)
VaRResult varResult = new VaRResult();
// Validate portfolio
if (portfolioHoldings == null || portfolioHoldings.Count == 0)
{
VaRResult varResult=new VaRResult();
if (null == portfolioHoldings || 0 == portfolioHoldings.Count)
{
varResult.Success=false;
varResult.Success = false;
varResult.Message = "Portfolio is null or empty.";
return varResult;
}
// This ensures that the pricing information for each holding is symmetric.
// The piece of code that checks for jagged pricing should be handled differently. For example, we should be able to continue the VaR analysis and simply account for no exposure to the
// given symbol in the event of a lack of pricing data. This would handle the current issue with securities that have been trading for less than the number of observation days.
if (portfolioHoldings.Count > 1)
// Determine the minimum common price history across holdings
int minPriceCount = int.MaxValue;
for (int i = 0; i < portfolioHoldings.Count; i++)
{
int priceCount=-1;
for (int index = 1; index < portfolioHoldings.Count; index++)
{
if(portfolioHoldings[index].Prices.Count>priceCount)priceCount=portfolioHoldings[index].Prices.Count;
int count = portfolioHoldings[i].Prices.Count;
if (count < minPriceCount)
minPriceCount = count;
}
for (int index = 1; index < portfolioHoldings.Count; index++)
// Enforce minimum observation requirement
if (minPriceCount < 30) // or whatever threshold you prefer
{
if (portfolioHoldings[index].Prices.Count != priceCount)
{
varResult.Success=false;
varResult.Message=String.Format("Insufficient price history for {0}. {1}/{2}",portfolioHoldings[index].Symbol,portfolioHoldings[index].Prices.Count,priceCount);
varResult.Success = false;
varResult.Message = $"Insufficient common price history ({minPriceCount} observations).";
return varResult;
}
// Truncate all holdings to the common window
for (int i = 0; i < portfolioHoldings.Count; i++)
{
if (portfolioHoldings[i].Prices.Count > minPriceCount)
{
portfolioHoldings[i].Prices = new MarketDataModel.Prices(
portfolioHoldings[i].Prices
.Skip(portfolioHoldings[i].Prices.Count - minPriceCount)
.ToList()
);
}
}
// Calculate total market value and then calculate the weightings of each holding
// Calculate total market value and holdings weightings
double marketValue = portfolioHoldings.GetMarketValue();
if (marketValue == 0)
{
varResult.Success = false;
varResult.Message = "Portfolio market value is zero.";
return varResult;
}
for (int index = 0; index < portfolioHoldings.Count; index++)
{
PortfolioHolding portfolioHolding = portfolioHoldings[index];
portfolioHolding.Weight = portfolioHolding.MarketValue / marketValue;
}
// Calculate the weighted returns for the observation period
// Calculate weighted returns for the observation period
portfolioHoldings.SetReturnDays(returnDays);
int numReturns=portfolioHoldings[0].Returns.Length;
WeightedReturnsWithContribution weightedReturnsWithContrbution=new WeightedReturnsWithContribution();
int numReturns = portfolioHoldings.Min(p => p.Returns.Length);
WeightedReturnsWithContribution weightedReturnsWithContribution = new WeightedReturnsWithContribution();
for (int index = 0; index < numReturns; index++)
{
for (int portfolioIndex = 0; portfolioIndex < portfolioHoldings.Count; portfolioIndex++)
{
PortfolioHolding portfolioHolding = portfolioHoldings[portfolioIndex];
WeightedReturn weightedReturn=new WeightedReturn(portfolioHolding.Symbol,portfolioHolding.Prices[index].Date,portfolioHolding.Returns[index] * portfolioHolding.Weight);
weightedReturnsWithContrbution.Add(index,weightedReturn);
WeightedReturn weightedReturn = new WeightedReturn(
portfolioHolding.Symbol,
portfolioHolding.Prices[index].Date,
portfolioHolding.Returns[index] * portfolioHolding.Weight
);
weightedReturnsWithContribution.Add(index, weightedReturn);
}
}
double[] weightedReturns=weightedReturnsWithContrbution.GetWeightedReturns();
List<Contributions> contributionsList=weightedReturnsWithContrbution.GetContributions();
// Organize the weighted returns into bins so we can access the nth percentile rank
// The VaR nth percentile VaR is simply the weighted return at the given rank (i.e.) 90%, 95%, 99% within the bin
// The VaR result will be a negative percent and negative amount to show that this is a loss. We display this as a positive number so we need to take the absolute value of the result
// ** To Do ** bring out the contributors to VaR at the given rank.
double[] weightedReturns = weightedReturnsWithContribution.GetWeightedReturns();
List<Contributions> contributionsList = weightedReturnsWithContribution.GetContributions();
// Organize the weighted returns into bins for percentile access
BinManager<Contributions> binManager = new BinManager<Contributions>();
BinResult<Contributions> binResult=binManager.GetVaRReturn(weightedReturns,contributionsList,percentile);
Contributions contributions=binResult.Item;
if(null==contributions){varResult.Success=false;return varResult;}
Dictionary<String,PortfolioHolding> portfolioHoldingsBySymbol=new Dictionary<String,PortfolioHolding>();
foreach(PortfolioHolding portfolioHolding in portfolioHoldings){if(!portfolioHoldingsBySymbol.ContainsKey(portfolioHolding.Symbol))portfolioHoldingsBySymbol.Add(portfolioHolding.Symbol,portfolioHolding);}
foreach(Contribution contribution in contributions)
BinResult<Contributions> binResult = binManager.GetVaRReturn(weightedReturns, contributionsList, percentile);
Contributions contributions = binResult.Item;
if (contributions == null)
{
if(!portfolioHoldingsBySymbol.ContainsKey(contribution.Symbol))continue;
portfolioHoldingsBySymbol[contribution.Symbol].Contribution=contribution.ContributionValue;
portfolioHoldingsBySymbol[contribution.Symbol].ContributionDate=contribution.AnalysisDate;
varResult.Success = false;
return varResult;
}
return new VaRResult(binResult.Value, portfolioHoldings.GetMarketValue() * binResult.Value);
// Map contributions back to portfolio holdings
Dictionary<string, PortfolioHolding> portfolioHoldingsBySymbol = new Dictionary<string, PortfolioHolding>();
foreach (PortfolioHolding portfolioHolding in portfolioHoldings)
{
if (!portfolioHoldingsBySymbol.ContainsKey(portfolioHolding.Symbol))
portfolioHoldingsBySymbol.Add(portfolioHolding.Symbol, portfolioHolding);
}
foreach (Contribution contribution in contributions)
{
if (!portfolioHoldingsBySymbol.ContainsKey(contribution.Symbol))
continue;
portfolioHoldingsBySymbol[contribution.Symbol].Contribution = contribution.ContributionValue;
portfolioHoldingsBySymbol[contribution.Symbol].ContributionDate = contribution.AnalysisDate;
}
return new VaRResult(binResult.Value, marketValue * binResult.Value);
}
public int ReturnDays
{
get { return returnDays; }
set { returnDays = value; }
get => returnDays;
set => returnDays = value;
}
}
}

View File

@@ -126,7 +126,6 @@ namespace MarketData.ValueAtRisk
}
public void SetReturnDays(int days)
{
if (returnDays == days) return;
returnDays = days;
returns = prices.GetReturnsAsDoubleArray(returnDays);
}